Limbaugh: Still No Competition
Those who derive solace from FOX, Laura, Sean, et al., nonetheless must regularly tune to the EIB Network for what cannot be found at any other time, at any other frequency. The reasons for Rush Limbaugh’s success also measure the staying power of others on the Right. As of now, the measure is not encouraging. Let’s consider this:
“Talk radio” is not the creation of Rush Limbaugh; it has been in place for more than a half-century, long serving the needs of a nation of insomniacs. But Limbaugh is to “talk radio” what talk itself was to motion pictures. He installed it as the veritable agenda of social and political discourse in a nation long dominated by three networks and their cadre of overpaid news readers. When he calls himself “the nation’s anchor man” a listener is not sure whether to chuckle or nod approvingly. Take any story covered by “the drive-by media”, listen to Limbaugh’s analysis of the same, and then try to recall any part of the network account. Don’t worry; it’s not your memory. By comparison, the networks score 96 on the AL GORE-BORE meter.
We now take for granted Rush Limbaugh’s actually astonishing ability to hold the attention of an informed and educated audience three hours, every day, without staging the conversational equivalent of Wrestlemania. There is no shouting, no parallel discursive universe, no rhetorical managerie. Airtime is not given over to morons and psychiatric cases. There is the occasional snippet — the Cindy Sheehan moment — effectively inserted to keep listeners aware of the grounds on which to distinguish the WHACKO from bona fide earthlings. Otherwise, the mind of the listener is able to enage another mind and, whether in agreement or antagonism, recognize the encounter as an engagement rather than a manipulation. For all the bravado and hijinks, Limbaugh radiates an integrity — yes, an intelligence — rare in the pompous world of talking but empty heads. He needs no “guest” to create the illusion of debate or to underscore the credibility of his own judgments. He picks and tarries over the foibles and evils of the day, paying them attention remarkably proportioned to their actual importance. He then moves on. The pace is steady, nearly rhythmic. And, when the hours have past, one has the distinct feeling that a quite interesting acquaintance has left one’s residence, then relieved by the assurance of a return visit.
Can’t the same be said of Sean Hannity, Bill O’Reilly, Laura Ingraham and lesser sentinels on the Right? Here MINDSATWORK strives for caution. Lord knows, they are ALL needed, ALL worthy of the thanks of the starved and thirsting. But it is just because of this that MINDSATWORK begins to worry about their shelf-life. Hannity and What’s-His-Name now preside over what is too often a shouting spree and freak show. Nights of examining the latest from something called “The View” — a program MINDSATWORK avoids as a threat to brain function — transforms much of the hour to a tiresome rant. Even the serious specialist, awkwardly fit in among such flotsam, is filtered out by the self-protective mechanisms of the adult nervous system.
So, too, with Bill O’Reilly’s descent into “Spring Break” and other really tawdry segments which have much less to do with “looking out for us” than with looking out for ratings. Sorry, Bill; you’re a good man, but porn is porn even when flashed to improve the character of the viewer.
Laura Ingraham, too, has proven to be so comfortable inside the Beltway, so eager to have listeners know how influential an ‘insider’ she is, that she actually comes across as a merely less offensive member of that influence-peddling industry populated by those whose main achievement is persistent networking. Where Limbaugh’s self-congratulatory claims are clearly ironic and amusing, Laura’s are serious, even strident, and, therefore, uselessly distracting. There is an undertone in all this; one that creates the suspicion that, had the cards been dealt just a little differently, Ms Ingraham might have popped up as a bullying feminist. Impressions are not facts, and MINDSATWORK cannot read minds at work. Still, Limbaugh IS a personality; the rest are still working at it.
So it’s time for MINDSATWORK to give its first ever award; this one to a man who has an unmatched record of candor, focus and contribution to civic discourse during the most recent two decades. It is a pity that his friends on the Right are far more eager to praise him than to follow his example.
http://mindsatwork.blogsome.com